Advertisement

Roo News

The Student News Site of University of Missouri - Kansas City

Roo News

Roo News

Around 1 million people were estimated to be in attendance at the parade.
One Dead, Several Injured During Chiefs Parade
Zach Gunter and Jazlyn SummersFebruary 14, 2024

Update:   As of 2:30 p.m. Thursday afternoon, the number of those injured at the Union Station shooting after the Chiefs Super Bowl parade...

UMKCDC regularly updates their practice schedule and have multiple sessions a month.
UMKC Dance Club Prepares for First Performance
Luis Marin, Staff Writer • February 14, 2024

The UMKC Dance Club wants to create a space for judgment-free dancing, one move at a time.      The new organization, also known as UMKCDC,...

The Rainbow Lounge can be found on the second floor of the Student Union.
The Pride Alliance Pushes for an Increase in Members
Manuel Rivera and Brenna OxleyFebruary 13, 2024

  After struggling to gain and keep members last semester, UMKC’s Pride Alliance club outlined their new agenda with plans to increase membership...

Valentines Day can be stressful for students trying to save money, luckily there are options to stay frugal and be fun.
Love on A Budget
Scarlett Gottschalk, Staff Writer • February 7, 2024

  As a college student, spoiling your partner without jeopardizing next week’s groceries on Valentine’s Day can be hard.   Here are...

Members of TAASU at a general body meeting.
UMKC's African American Student Union Brings Community for Students
Amina Shaw, Staff Writer • February 6, 2024

  The African American Student Union (TAASU) works to foster a sense of belonging and empowerment for African American students by providing...

Opinion: Appointing RBG’s successor: should it wait until after the election?

Opinion: Appointing RBG’s successor: should it wait until after the election?

Following the death of Justice Antonin Scalia in 2016, Republicans within the Senate, most notably Kentucky Senator Mitch McConnell, refused to hold hearings for a potential nominee. The move frustrated many Democratic lawmakers who found the decision to be obviously political. “This obstruction is unprecedented,” Senator Tom Udall of New Mexico said in an official statement.

The justification by Republicans at the time was simple. “All we are doing is following the long-standing tradition of not fulfilling a nomination in the middle of a presidential year,” McConnell said in a 2016 Fox News interview. The nomination process, which lasted a total of 293 days, ended in a stand-still.

The situation is now repeating, though with a significantly different spin. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg passed away less than 50 days before the upcoming election, and Republican lawmakers are moving quickly to fill the empty seat, despite the fact that the nation is in a presidential year.

Many leaders within the Democratic Party have called for a delay in the nomination until the election has been decided, citing Republican’s actions in 2016. “The American people should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court Justice,” Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said on Sept. 18.

Despite this, President Trump announced a nomination on Saturday. And, as expected, this resulted in a large amount of backlash from the left. Republicans have countered accusations of hypocrisy by explaining what they believe is a crucial distinction between the current situation and the one in 2016. 

This election year, the same party controls the White House and the Senate, unlike in 2016. McConnell has now argued that, rather than there being a general precedent for not appointing a nominee during an election year, the precedent is not allowing a nomination during an election year where the legislature and executive are divided.

Yet, the evidence doesn’t add up. Of the 13 appointments that took place during an election year (post-Civil War), two of them came during a partisan split. The first came during 1956, when President Eisenhower made an uncontested recess appointment in October. The second was in 1988 and resulted in the confirmation of former Justice Robert Kennedy, who retired in 2018. It should be noted that while the confirmation of Kennedy happened during an election year, the vacancy and nomination occurred during the previous year. 

Looking at this, McConnell’s explanation falls apart. But his argument isn’t the end of the ridiculous Republican justifications for their blatant insincerity. 

“Make no mistake: if the shoe were on the other foot, Senate Democrats wouldn’t hesitate to use their Constitutional authority and anything else at their disposal to fill this seat,” said Chuck Grassley, a senator from Iowa.

There are two particularly striking aspects about this statement. 

First, this is a pretty childish defense that essentially boils down to “well they’d do it too!” That’s certainly not the rationale most people would like to hear behind such an important decision at the highest levels of governance. Especially one that has the potential to determine how the Supreme Court, as a collective, will interpret the Constitution for years to come. 

Second, it’s an admission that at least some members of the party aren’t even under the illusion that they are following precedent, they are just fine with being obstructionists. The inclusion of the phrase “anything else at their disposal” is a significant hint at their intent. They are willing to do anything they can to prevent Democrats from getting a liberal appointee on the bench, even if it’s outside of traditional “Constitutional authority.”

All-in-all, it’s not a surprising move to anyone who has been watching how McConnell has operated these past few years. He’s continued a push to expand conservative influences wherever possible, even if it flies in the face of normal precedent. This is just his most recent attempt.

[email protected]

Leave a Comment
Donate to Roo News

Your donation will support the student journalists of University of Missouri - Kansas City. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
Donate to Roo News

Comments (0)

All Roo News Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *