Roo News

The Student News Site of University of Missouri - Kansas City

Roo News

Roo News

Around 1 million people were estimated to be in attendance at the parade.
One Dead, Several Injured During Chiefs Parade
Zach Gunter and Jazlyn Summers February 14, 2024

Update:   As of 2:30 p.m. Thursday afternoon, the number of those injured at the Union Station shooting after the Chiefs Super Bowl parade...

UMKCDC regularly updates their practice schedule and have multiple sessions a month.
UMKC Dance Club Prepares for First Performance
Luis Marin, Staff Writer • February 14, 2024

The UMKC Dance Club wants to create a space for judgment-free dancing, one move at a time.      The new organization, also known as UMKCDC,...

The Rainbow Lounge can be found on the second floor of the Student Union.
The Pride Alliance Pushes for an Increase in Members
Manuel Rivera and Brenna Oxley February 13, 2024

  After struggling to gain and keep members last semester, UMKC’s Pride Alliance club outlined their new agenda with plans to increase membership...

Valentines Day can be stressful for students trying to save money, luckily there are options to stay frugal and be fun.
Love on A Budget
Scarlett Gottschalk, Staff Writer • February 7, 2024

  As a college student, spoiling your partner without jeopardizing next week’s groceries on Valentine’s Day can be hard.   Here are...

Members of TAASU at a general body meeting.
UMKC's African American Student Union Brings Community for Students
Amina Shaw, Staff Writer • February 6, 2024

  The African American Student Union (TAASU) works to foster a sense of belonging and empowerment for African American students by providing...

UMKC SGA Supreme Court upholds confirmation of vice president


The UMKC Student Government Association (SGA) Supreme Court has decided to uphold the SGA Senate confirmation of Daphne Posadas as SGA’s new vice president, it announced on Dec. 7. The decision comes less than a week after SGA Senator Trenton Garza filed a petition against the confirmation, citing that the senate had “exceeded its discretion” in confirming a nominee without holding internal interviews.

Posadas, the former SGA chief of staff, was nominated immediately after the swearing in of former Vice President Mahreen Ansari as the new SGA president on Nov. 30. The senate confirmed her nomination in a nearly-unanimous vote, with Garza having cast the only vote against Posadas. 

The court’s decision was made by only three justices, rather than the usual seven. The remaining four justices’ terms expired on Dec. 2, and the positions await nominees from Ansari. The three justices presiding were Chief Justice Alexander Higgenbotham, Justice Jasmine Ward and Justice Chase Ford.

The court ruled that because the vice president position is normally voted on by students, and not confirmed by the senate, it is not logical to require Posadas to undergo procedures that she would otherwise not have to go through.

Despite there being no evidence in the SGA Constitution to require an interview, the court explored whether or not there was an implied requirement for a hearing. Garza stated that senate bylaws have explicit mandates for Supreme Court nominees to undergo a hearing as an implied requirement.

However, the court stated that the explicit difference in the mandates for court and vice presidential nominees was intentional. If the processes for the court nominees were meant to apply to vice presidential nominees, the court said, the Constitution would have said so.

The court argued that Garza’s request to override the senate’s vote and Ansari’s appointment would be an abuse of the SGA’s judicial power.

Removing the current vice president is a very serious action, the court said, and one that should only be taken if absolutely necessary.

According to the court’s official opinion, Garza repeatedly argued that the SGA Constitution was poorly written, which the court refused to consider as an argument in the case. If Garza had a problem with the constitution, the court said, he should introduce changes in the senate.

Garza also argued that Posadas did not “receive proper debate or scrutiny” as there was no interview by an internal committee. However, the court argued that because she was questioned by the senate on the night of her confirmation, it took the place of an internal committee interview.

The court also argued that the senate knowingly waived the requirement for an interview by voting for Posadas.

[email protected]

[email protected]

Leave a Comment
Donate to Roo News

Your donation will support the student journalists of University of Missouri - Kansas City. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
Donate to Roo News

Comments (0)

All Roo News Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *